Skip to content

Welcome to our new website. Consultations are available in person in Irving or online by video. Request a consultation

Immigration

Is Adjustment of Status Still Safe? What USCIS's 2026 Policies Mean for Green Card Applicants

Two USCIS policies issued in 2026 have made green card applications filed inside the United States riskier. Here is what changed, who is most affected, and what pending and future applicants should do now.

Wohidul Islam· LL.M., Harvard Law SchoolPublished Updated
Illustration of a green card application under a magnifying glass with the title "Is Adjustment of Status Still Safe?"

Quick answer

It is still available, but riskier than before. Since May 2026, USCIS officers treat choosing adjustment of status over consular processing as a negative factor, and since August they can deny applications without first requesting more evidence. Both policies are being challenged in federal court but remain in effect. A complete, well-documented filing matters more than ever.

For most of the last seventy years, a person who qualified for a green card while living lawfully in the United States had a straightforward option. They could file Form I-485 with USCIS, wait here with their family, keep working, and attend an interview in a local field office. That process is called adjustment of status, and Congress built it into Section 245 of the Immigration and Nationality Act in 1952.

That option still exists. But in 2026, USCIS changed the way its officers are told to look at it, and the change is serious enough that every pending and future applicant should understand it. If you have a case pending, you have probably asked yourself some version of this question: "Is my green card application still safe?" This article is our attempt to answer that question honestly, in plain English.

The May 2026 memo: adjustment of status as "extraordinary" relief

On May 21, 2026, USCIS issued Policy Memorandum PM-602-0199. The memo reminds officers that adjustment of status is discretionary, which is not new. Even a fully eligible applicant has never had an absolute right to approval.

What is new is the starting point. The memo describes adjustment as an extraordinary form of relief that lets applicants skip the "ordinary" route of applying for an immigrant visa at a U.S. consulate abroad. Officers are directed to treat the applicant's choice to adjust here, rather than consular process, as a negative factor. To overcome that negative factor, the applicant must show positive equities strong enough to justify approval. The memo uses the phrase "unusual or even outstanding" to describe them.

In practical terms, the burden has shifted. Before May, an eligible applicant with a clean record was generally approved. Under the memo, the officer may ask a different question: why should this person get a green card here instead of going home to get it?

The August 2026 policy: denials without a second chance

The second change came on August 5, 2026, in Policy Alert PA-2026-05. Many applicants have come to rely on a familiar safety net: if something was missing from the file, USCIS would send a Request for Evidence (RFE) or a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) and give them time to fix it.

That safety net is now much thinner. Officers may deny an application outright if required initial evidence is missing or if the filing, as submitted, does not establish eligibility. A partial response to an RFE can be treated as a request for a decision on the record as it stands.

The part that troubles us most is timing. The August policy applies to applications that were already pending when it took effect. Think about what that means. Someone who filed in 2025 had no reason to argue why they deserved to adjust here instead of abroad, because that question did not exist yet. Now their file may be judged against the May standard, and the officer is not required to ask them for more before deciding.

Why a denial costs more than people expect

A denied I-485 is not simply a "no, try again later." For many people, the application itself is what keeps their life in place. A denial can bring several problems at once:

  • Loss of work and travel permission. A work permit and advance parole issued based on the pending I-485 can end when the application is denied.

  • Loss of lawful presence. A properly filed adjustment application generally puts the applicant in a period of authorized stay. Once it is denied, someone without another valid status may begin accruing unlawful presence, and the case may be referred to immigration court.

  • Lost time and fees. Many applicants have waited a year or more. Starting over means paying the filing fees again and going back to the end of the line.

This is also why "just go back home and do consular processing" is not a simple fix. A person who has already accrued unlawful presence in the U.S. can trigger a three-year or ten-year bar to returning the moment they depart. A waiver is available only to certain applicants and requires a showing of extreme hardship to a qualifying relative. For some families, leaving the country is the riskiest move they could make, and it should never be done without legal advice.

The lawsuit: AAUP v. Mullin

On October 5, 2026, a coalition filed suit in federal court in Boston: American Association of University Professors et al. v. Mullin, No. 1:26-cv-14527 (D. Mass.). The plaintiffs include faculty associations, the Service Employees International Union and two of its affiliates, a Florida legal aid organization, and six individual green card applicants.

They argue that both policies violate the Administrative Procedure Act. Their main points are that USCIS has no authority to penalize people for using a process Congress created, that the agency skipped notice-and-comment rulemaking, and that applying the August policy to pending cases is unfair to people who filed under the old rules. One plaintiff, a woman who has lived in the U.S. since 1998, was reportedly denied in September even though USCIS found her eligible.

USCIS sees it differently. The agency says the May memo restores the original intent of the law, and that applicants have always been responsible for proving eligibility when they file.

Where things stand today: the plaintiffs have asked for a preliminary injunction, but as of the date of this article, we are not aware of any court order blocking either policy. Both remain in effect, and USCIS continues to apply them to new and pending cases. We will update this article if the court rules.

Who should pay the closest attention

The policies apply to adjustment applicants generally, but some groups face more risk than others:

  • People who entered on a temporary visa and later became eligible for a green card. This includes visitors, students, and workers who married a U.S. citizen or received an employment-based or investor petition. The memo's reasoning focuses on people who came temporarily and are now seeking to stay permanently.

  • Employment-based and EB-5 applicants who filed concurrently. Many of these files were prepared to prove eligibility, not to argue discretion, because discretion was rarely an issue before.

  • Anyone whose application was filed before August 5, 2026, with a lean file. If the officer finds something missing, there may be no RFE.

  • Applicants with complications in their history, such as a past status gap, an old arrest, a prior visa denial, or inconsistent dates on earlier forms. Under a discretionary standard, small problems carry more weight.

Spouses and parents of U.S. citizens are still subject to the policy. Early reports from practitioners suggest fewer changes in outcomes for these families so far, but that is an observation, not a guarantee, and no one should rely on it.

What we recommend right now

If your I-485 is already pending:

  1. Have your file reviewed now, before an officer reviews it. Look at what was actually submitted, not what you remember submitting.

  2. Consider sending a supplemental filing that addresses discretion directly. Family ties in the U.S., length of residence, steady employment, tax compliance, community involvement, property, and any hardship that departure would cause are all worth documenting.

  3. Answer every RFE completely and on time. Under the new policy, a partial answer can lead straight to a decision.

  4. Keep any separate status you have, such as H-1B, L-1, or E-2, valid while the case is pending. That status is your backup if something goes wrong.

  5. Do not travel without advance parole or a valid visa that allows it, and talk to your lawyer before any trip.

If you are planning to file:

  1. Treat the first filing as your only chance. Submit every piece of required initial evidence and make sure the forms are on the current edition.

  2. Build the discretionary case into the filing from day one, with a short legal brief and supporting documents.

  3. Compare adjustment and consular processing with your lawyer before choosing. For some people, especially those who are outside the U.S. or have no unlawful presence issues, consular processing may now be the better route. For others, leaving the country could create a bar to coming back. This is a case-by-case decision.

  4. Never assume you can "fix it later." That was often true before August. It is not something to count on now.

The bottom line

Adjustment of status has not been abolished. USCIS is still accepting I-485 applications and still approving them. What has changed is the margin for error. A file that would have passed easily two years ago, or would have drawn an RFE, can now end in a denial.

The good news is that most of the risk can be reduced with careful preparation. A complete, well-documented filing that tells the officer clearly why you deserve approval is the best protection available while the courts decide whether these policies will stand.

If you have a pending application, or you are deciding whether to file in the U.S. or apply abroad, we are glad to review your situation. Summit Law USA offers consultations in person in Irving, Texas, and by video nationwide. Reach us at (469) 472-9153 or reach@summitlawusa.com.


This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration policy is changing quickly, and the right strategy depends on the facts of each case. Please consult an attorney before acting on any information here.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is USCIS still approving adjustment of status applications in 2026?

Yes. USCIS continues to accept and approve Form I-485 applications. Since May 2026, however, officers are told to treat the choice to adjust status in the U.S. as a negative discretionary factor, so applicants should document the positive factors that support approval.

Can USCIS deny my green card application without sending a Request for Evidence?

Yes. Under a policy effective August 5, 2026, officers may deny an application without an RFE or NOID if required initial evidence is missing or the filing does not establish eligibility. The policy also applies to applications that were already pending.

Should I leave the U.S. and apply through consular processing instead?

Not without legal advice. Consular processing can be a good option for some applicants, but a person who has accrued unlawful presence may trigger a three-year or ten-year bar to reentry by departing. The right choice depends on your immigration history.

Does the AAUP v. Mullin lawsuit protect my pending application?

Not at this time. The lawsuit asks a federal court in Massachusetts to block both policies, but filing it did not suspend them. Unless a court rules otherwise, USCIS continues to apply both policies to new and pending cases.

Do these policies apply to spouses of U.S. citizens?

Yes. The policies apply to adjustment applicants generally, including spouses and other immediate relatives of U.S. citizens. Some practitioners report fewer changes in outcomes for these cases so far, but that is not guaranteed.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and government policies change; please consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Have a question about this topic?